Cherry Tree Carol: Redux
To preface this, Sharon is a big Mixdorf fan.
That said, upon reading his comments on this song, Mixdorf, Sharon's reaction was one of, "who says it's just some narrative that has no connection to anything? It's a traditional song. What if it has a long history behind it and come connection to something bigger that we just don't know about?" On Sunday night, she got around to looking it up in Wikipedia. The history went a lot farther back than even she realized. It's actually directly from one of the gospels, albeit not one of the gospels that made it into our modern day Bibles-the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew. The very interesting history of the song is here. My favorite part of the article is at the end, when it details the song retelling's differences from the actual "events:"
...Joseph's truculence is unrelated to any dismay over Mary's pregnancy, but has to do with an inability to reach the fruits of the palm and a concern over the family's lack of water.